Westlaw Canada Logo
CriminalSource
Neuberger Rose


The Neuberger Rose Criminal Law Advisor, by leading defence counsel David Rose, provides expert analysis on current issues of interest to criminal practitioners across Canada. It features highlights of key legislative developments, case comments and summaries of trial level decisions covering a wide range of matters including the Charter, forensic and electronic evidence. The newsletter is published on a monthly basis.

Excerpts from Newsletter 2011-7 – Read the latest newsletter 

(the full version is available to CriminalSource subscribers). 

Headlines

The Supreme Court clarifies the law of consent.

Trial courts may fix the hourly rate of amicus curiae according to the Ontario Court of Appeal.

The mens rea for perjury may include mental capacity and linguistic ability of the accused.

The accused threw one punch, and is acquitted of aggravated assault.

 Evasive answers give rise to a reasonable doubt.

 

Selected Case 

 

Consent to sexual activity must be made by an individual who is conscious throughout the sexual activity. Thus, in a case where the complainant had been in the habit of engaging in consensual choking during sexual activity for arousal, and the accused had penetrated her whilst she was unconscious, there was no consent in law. The trial judge properly convicted of sexual assault on the basis that consent could not be given during such unconsciousness. Neither the Criminal Code nor jurisprudence supports the idea that consent may be given in advance. To rule otherwise would be to negate the person from changing her mind about the contact at any point in the sexual encounter.

R. v. A. (J.), 2011 CarswellOnt 3515, 2011 CarswellOnt 3516 (S.C.C.)

Raise the bar on legal research with CriminalSource. Fast, simple, reliable and comprehensive – our service reflects our philosophy. CriminalSource delivers extensive finding tools, full integration and linking, plus multiple search options. CriminalSource … indepth content and powerful functionality that allow flexibility in work style, and so elecgantly simple to use that it really does let you work the way you think. Subscribe now!